Poll: Should Merrick make changes to last week’s lineup?

After reading the comments on Saturday’s game, it’s clear that many of you quite impressed with the Melbourne Victory’s performance against Adelaide United.

The inclusion of Kaz Patafta in the starting line-up was one major cause for celebration, as I talked about yesterday.

The success of last week’s starting lineup raises some interesting questions for this week. With Danny Allsopp returning from injury, Steve Pantelidis no longer on suspension, and Nick Ward joining the team, Ernie Merrick has some serious selection headaches.

Over to you: Should Merrick make any changes to last week’s starting lineup?

Vote in the sidebar and leave your comments below!

***

Last week’s poll is now closed.

When asked whether you think Melbourne can still make the finals, 32 said yes, while 30 don’t think it’s possible.

Funnily enough, despite Melbourne coming away from Saturday night with a draw, a slight majority still reckon we can make the finals.

6 comments ↓

#1 Eric on 12.12.07 at 4:54 pm

ps. Here’s last week’s lineup for those of you who have forgotten:

Goal: Michael Theoklitos
Defense: Sebastian Ryall – Kevin Muscat – Rodrigo Vargas – Matthew Kemp
Midfield: Leigh Broxham – Adrian Caceres – Kaz Patafta – Daniel Vasilevski
Forwards: Carlos Hernandez – Archie Thompson

#2 Astri on 12.12.07 at 9:22 pm

Play a 3-4-3 with Alsopp replacing Kemp.

#3 skippadude on 12.12.07 at 10:43 pm

play a 3-4-3 with nick ward replacing kemp

#4 Josh on 12.13.07 at 7:55 am

Definitely.

4-5-1 counter-attack that pushes to 4-3-3 when sustaining the attack:
Theo
Panta, Ryall, Vargas, Keenan
Muscat
Vasilevski – Hernandez – Patafta
Archie

Bench: Danny, Carceras, Ward

Ward on for Vas/Hernandez if we need some oomph (60 minutes)
Carceras on for Patafta when he looks tired (70?)

Danny for Vas/Patafta if we need a goal, switch to 3-5-2 (keenan up to LWB, Panta on RWB)

If we need to hold the lead, Vas into RB, Ryall to LB, Keenan into 2nd DMF alongside muscat. That’s 4-5-1 with 2 DMF, still capable of a good counter-attack.

Too much Football Manager for me :D

#5 Josh on 12.13.07 at 2:31 pm

Erm, the above originally had Breb/Broxham alongside Muscat.

Theo
Panta, Ryall, Vargas, Keenan
Muscat, Broxham
Vasilevski – Hernandez – Patafta
Archie

#6 David on 12.13.07 at 9:30 pm

Changes should be made but only Keenan for Kemp and Pantelidis back in at the expense of Broxham, with Muscat moving back into defensive midfield. Consistency in midfield has been part of the problem this year, so I can’t see Merrick making wholesale changes from last week, he should keep the nucleus and strengthen where possible.

Theoklitos
Pantelidis Ryall Vargas Keenan
Vasilevski Muscat Patafta Caceres
Thompson Hernandez

Bench – Allsopp Ward Broxham

Leave a Comment